Friday, May 9, 2014

Am I Angry, overcritical, or am I getting at something larger?

I never wonder if I’m just angry, a little too sensitive, or I lack the sense of humor needed. Yet, those are statements that get thrown at me more often then I care to hear them.  In a way those statements are oppressive and when spoken these statements are saying that I have no right to feel what I feel, that I am somehow imaging the underlying sexism in our society.  When I call something or someone out and someone says “you’re too sensitive” or laughs at what I say in a given situation. They are just continuing to perpetuate these stereotypes and social norms because they are failing to question their beliefs and question why this is the norm. In this case ignorance is not bliss, not for me and certainly not for those who spout phrases like “it’s just a joke.”


Recently, there has been a series of cross promotional Carl’s JR and X-Men: Days of Future Past commercials. One has aired in which we see Mystique holding a hamburger and then she shape shifts into a man and a tag comes on the screen that reads “man up for the 2x of bacon.”  There has been another commercial with Colossus with the same hamburger its tag is “colossal amounts of bacon” 


I feel like this is just a small example of this covert sexism that is like a greasy and dingy film that coats our society. I find that this dingy layer of grease has become so thick and has been present in our culture for so long that it seems normal to most.  These commercials seems like nothing but to take something like the X-men that‘s entire premise is acceptance and equality for all no matter who they are be the person human or mutant. Than to use these characters, in such way that says you have to identify as a male to enjoy this or don’t even think about enjoying this heart attack in bun. It is infuriating to see something that promotes equality be manipulated to sell food mostly because the people who created these commercials have subtle prejudices that have never been put in check.  Furthermore, because of this omnipresent sexism I find myself saying sentences like “I like this show/movie/book but…” and really you could fill at the blank in with anything. It could be poorly written female characters with plots that lack any real variation or the only purpose they serve is to further the male character’s plot.  As someone who consumes a fair amount of media, I am forced to look at who is telling these stories and why? Moreover, I find myself struggling with how I deal the latent sexism in the media; I can choose not to consume most of it but what about the media I choose to consume? Knowing its present and trying to differentiate between commenting on sexism through characters or the creators are actually sexist. Furthermore, I believe the most important thing a consumer of media can do is criticize and take apart the show to recognize what makes you uncomfortable and to hold the media accountable for its actions.    

What is even more surprising is that I have to police myself or rather remind myself that a good representation of women is a varied representation.  For the longest time I got angry when I saw a female character portrayed as weak, reliant on others, emotional, as the stick in the mud, and so on. The realization that what makes a good female character is complexity and variation because not every woman is a gun slinging, stoic, angry, machine like character. This realization came slowly then hit me like a ton of bricks when I watched the show Breaking Bad.  Skylar White probably the least offensive character on the show received so much hate from people who claimed to be fans of the show. That actress Anna Gunn who portrayed the character even wrote an op-ed for the New York Times expressing her surprise and discomfort in finding out how much people hated her character.  The epiphany I had was that if a female character does not conform to the consumer’s idea of what women should be than there is something wrong with them. Or rather people have a problem when female characters interfere with the male characters adventures. I have found that if a woman experiences trauma and acts accordingly or a woman who stands up for herself in a way that is combative with the male protagonist, a lot of people have a problem with it. My views have changed because obviously real women real complex human beings and should be portrayed as such, but most importantly if people are getting angry at Skylar White type characters then someone is doing something right.

“Could it be that they can’t stand a woman who won’t suffer silently or “stand by her man”? That they despise her because she won’t back down or give up? Or because she is, in fact, Walter’s equal?” –Anna Gunn on her character in Breaking Bad

This idea of controlling and in a way oppressing women through stereotypes and hateful speech isn't exclusive to the entertainment industry and those who enjoy it.  Men in politics continually use gender as an attack whether it’s to say that a particular female politician is “too emotional” or “she’s a nagging bitch.”  Politics seems to be a double edge sword, if women aren't dealing with the cheap shots from male politicians who can’t think of anything smart to say than women are dealing with pundits commenting on their looks and age rather than policies. A person that comes readily to minds is Hillary Rodham Clinton, with comments spewed in her direction like “She-devil” “who has only gotten as far as she has because her husband has messed around.” Which was sent out into the world by MSNBC’s Chris Matthews and never apologized for and another example would when editor at NPR, Ken Rubin,  went on CNN and compared her to Glenn Closes’ in Fatal Attraction saying  “She’s going to keep coming back, and they’re not going to stop her."

Or how about Senator Dianne Feinstein a democrat from California who leads the senate intelligence committee and lead the investigation into the CIA’s interrogation program during the Bush administration. Feinstein had found that torture was in practice more often than originally reported and when the former CIA director was asked about the findings he said that Feinstein had too much “emotional feeling” and the report could not be and “objective report” as a result.  The people who make these comments are obviously sexist in the sense that they are relying on the men vs. women we’re just so different line of thinking. Furthermore, they use these “inherent differences” to attack and you begin to wonder why. Well I think Anna Gunn’s comments on why people hated her character provides perfect insight.  These male politicians and pundits use gender as a form of an attack because these women won’t back down or give up and they are most often than not their equal. 

Links to Jon Stewart's take on Sexism and politics:
The Broads Must Be Crazy: Hillary Clinton and Sen. Dianne Feinstein receive different treatment than their male counterparts.

The Broads Must Be Crazy - Belittled Women: Double standards for elected officials indicate that sexism is alive and well in politics.

 When I was given this assignment I didn't know what to expect from both the research and the interview and to be quite on honest I was terrified and a little nervous.  I know how feel and I know how I came about that the information that changed my point of view, I just didn't know what I was going to find.  I was nervous because I know how I put information together and perceive things but maybe what I knew was nothing in comparison to what might be the truth.  In an article I found on poynter.org, I found a quote that shocked me to the point I had address it in my interview. In the article, Women’s media President Julie Burton is quoted saying “The media is failing women across the board.”  Well, immediately I thought that I was going to learn something new that day. Then I thought I knew it was bad but could it be failing across the board bad.

I found that the general message of my research as it related to the profession of the person I was interviewing that the people who work in journalism, people who are informing people and telling the public how to react in times of stress are overwhelmingly white men.  One of the most disconcerting statistics I found was that there are four times as many male columnists than female columnists in the top three newspapers. Moreover, the median age was 60 while the median age for the American population is only 37. This is such a shocking statistic and the more I looked into it the more I found that there was more statistics to support this shocking piece of information.  As reported in the status of women in the media, female journalist report more on lifestyle, culture, and health rather than politics, crime, and technology. Women also are made 36.1% of byline and on-screen contributions while men make 63.4%. If these statistics weren't discouraging enough, in an article specifically about media failing women it stated that a newsroom census showed that men make up 63.1% and women make up 36.9% of all newsrooms in 1999 and the number hasn't changed much since then. After doing this research, I was worried about whose story is getting told not just stories that are important to women but stories that are important to people of color. Moreover, if there isn't diversity amongst people who report on stories that matter the most to them than we are only getting a very narrow look at the world which is not okay. 
After I completed the process of completing my questions I wanted a little perspective into why the information I researched is the way it is so I framed my questions around a lot of the statistics. Yet when I sat down with my interviewee  I wasn't prepared to receive the answers that I got.When I sat down with my interviewee who will remain nameless because I forgot to mention this would go on a blog but my interviewee works as a director and general manager of a public radio station here in Milwaukee and he has a background in television and journalism.   A lot of what he said contradicted my research and not in way that that suggested this I’m a male and I know best kind of way but in a way that suggested he knew to the contrary.  The answer he gave to a lot of my questions was women were really excelling in the field already. Moreover, a lot of questions that required experiences as answers which I felt like I wasn't getting because he didn’t go through the experiences needed to answer them.  So I pushed the interview towards more data related questions, I asked …

Do you agree or disagree with the statement “that the media is failing women across the board?’
Then immediately followed up with question six and my rational because I released how vague it sounded.

Why do you think that men make up 63.1 percent of newsroom staff while women only make up 36.9 percent and do you have any thoughts on why this number hasn't changed since 1999?

Rational: In an article on Poynter.org stated that an ASNE newsroom census cited in the report showed that newsrooms were 63.1 percent male and 36.9 percent female in 1999. In 2012, those percentages were exactly the same.  As well as, that women are rarely sports journalists and those who are get judged on their looks. 

To this he replied I want to know the context of the quote and the sources.

That one sentence changed the way I thought because the quote was given without context and most likely intended to shock and outrage poynter readers. I’ll admit that I thought when I left the interview that maybe the conclusions I had drawn were wrong. Things seemed pretty good from his point of view and he even gave me a tour of the offices showing how many women worked there.  I really think that maybe we as a society should try to highlight women’s accomplishments as well as point out the injustices so we can begin to move forward. On the other hand, when I talked to people about my experience I was reminded of who interviewee was and his experiences as a man in a media based profession are not and would not be the same as a women going down the same path. Yet I cannot dismiss what I found in my research or what my interviewee said because both show we are make good but small strides and that we have a long way to go in the name of equality.

Resources:

http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/top-stories/240240/media-is-failing-women-sports-journalism-particularly-so/

http://time.com/8788/9-depressing-facts-from-the-latest-women-in-media-report/

http://wmc.3cdn.net/6dd3de8ca65852dbd4_fjm6yck9o.pdf

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2013/jun/14/top-10-sexist-moments-politics

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/13/us/politics/13women.html?pagewanted=all&_r=1&

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/24/opinion/i-have-a-character-issue.html?_r=0 

http://www.politicususa.com/2014/04/23/jon-stewart-highlights-blatant-sexism-politics-medias-double-standard.html